Prompt pudding containers are handy, however there’s nothing fairly just like the wealthy, creamy indulgence of do-it-yourself. This butterscotch pudding is made with darkish brown sugar for an unbeatable depth of taste. It’s fast and easy to make and velvety {smooth}. You’ll by no means return to a field!
You might also be keen on our sea salt caramel sauce or strive your hand at our do-it-yourself butterscotch caramels.
Why Our Recipe
- Decadent butterscotch pudding comprised of scratch with heavy cream.
- Fast and easy to prep in below quarter-hour.
- Serve your pudding heat or chill it fully and prime with freshly whipped cream.
This pudding may be served heat for a comfy, comforting deal with which is all the time pretty within the colder seasons. Or you may chill it fully and prime it with freshly whipped cream for a chilly dessert. Both method, you’ll have a crowd-pleasing favourite!
Ingredient Notes


- Darkish Brown Sugar: That is the important thing to the pudding’s butterscotch taste. (Enjoyable truth, brown sugar is what differentiates butterscotch from caramel which makes use of common granulated sugar). Gentle brown sugar can be utilized, however the taste gained’t be as intense.
- Cornstarch: Helps thicken the pudding to a superbly {smooth} consistency. You’ll want to whisk it effectively with the milk and cream to keep away from lumps.
- Heavy Cream: You possibly can substitute with half-and-half, however the pudding will likely be much less indulgent.
- Milk: Complete milk works finest for a creamy pudding, however 2% milk can be used.
- Egg Yolks: Important for making a thick, custard-like pudding. Mood them rigorously to keep away from scrambling.
- Salted Butter: Provides a contact of saltiness and velvety end to stability the sweetness. Unsalted butter can be utilized, however add a pinch of salt for the perfect taste.
- Vanilla Extract: Enhances the butterscotch taste. For an additional contact of luxurious, you should use vanilla bean paste or a recent vanilla bean.
Enjoyable Taste Variations
Salted Butterscotch: Stir in a pinch of flaky sea salt earlier than serving for a salted caramel vibe.
Bourbon Butterscotch: Add 1 tablespoon of bourbon together with the vanilla for a grown-up choice.
Spiced Butterscotch: Combine in 1/4 teaspoon of cinnamon or nutmeg for a heat, spiced taste.


Tempering Egg Yolks
Tempering egg yolks is a key step in making silky-smooth butterscotch pudding. It prevents the yolks from curdling by regularly bringing them as much as temperature. A gradual hand and steady whisking will guarantee a superbly creamy outcome each time.
Whisk the Yolks: Place the egg yolks in a small bowl and whisk till {smooth}. You possibly can even do that earlier than you begin cooking to make sure you have the whole lot able to go.
Add Scorching Pudding Slowly: Whereas whisking the yolks always, add just a few tablespoons of the recent pudding combination one spoonful at a time. This step warms the yolks gently with out cooking them.
Incorporate Again Into the Pudding: As soon as tempered, slowly pour the yolk combination again into the saucepan with the pudding, whisking repeatedly. This ensures the egg yolks mix seamlessly into the pudding with out forming lumps or clumps.
Stopping Pores and skin From Forming
A typical situation with do-it-yourself pudding is the formation of a thick pores and skin on the floor because it cools. Some folks love the pores and skin, however in case you don’t, it’s straightforward to keep away from. As soon as the pudding is transferred to serving dishes or a big bowl, press plastic wrap immediately onto the floor. This blocks air publicity, which is what causes the pores and skin to type.
Storage Directions
Refrigerate leftovers in an hermetic container for as much as 3 days. To stop a pores and skin from forming, press plastic wrap immediately onto the floor of the pudding earlier than sealing the container. Pudding just isn’t appropriate for freezing.
Extra scrumptious pudding recipes…
Trending Merchandise

Elite Gourmet EOM205 Non-Stick Omelet, Frittata, Snack Pocket Maker, Dessert Maker, 2 Individual 6.5″ Omelets, Stainless Steel and Black

Bencailor 4 Pcs Sunflower Kitchen Towels Summer Sea Beach Flower Floral Cow Kitchen Dish Towels Fast Drying Kitchen Decor for Cooking(Yellow,Sunflower)

Vacuum Sealer Machine, SEATAO 80Kpa Food Vacuum Sealer Machine Preservation Dry/Moist Modes, Handle Locked Design, Removable Drip Tray, Built-in Cutter and Bag Storage

ASSURED SIGNS Stylish Dishwasher Magnet Clean Dirty Sign – 2 by 7 Inch – Ideal Clean Dirty Magnet for Dishwasher – Kitchen Organizer and Gadget – Nice Office, Home Farmhouse Decor

Der Rose Fake Plants 4 Packs Artificial Plants Small Faux Plants Black Bathroom Accessories for Bathroom Home Office Desk Decor Indoor

Der Rose 4 Pack Fake Plants Mini Artificial Greenery Potted Plants for Home Decor Indoor Office Table Room Farmhouse

Mordimy 100% Cotton Waffle Weave Kitchen Towels, 13 x 28 Inches, Super Soft and Absorbent Buffalo Check Dish Towels for Drying Dishes, 4-Pack, Black & White
